Book review: ‘The Magic Hour’ by Kristin Hannah

By LARRY BALLWAHN | Wilton

When one of Dr. Julia Cates’ pediatric patients committed a horrific murder, she was sued on the basis that she must have known her patient’s mental state, or if not, she should have. After a year of dealing with the media and having her standing as a leading child psychologist ruined, the judge ruled that she could not be held responsible and released her from the case. The damage was done.

As Julia was struggling to gain her equilibrium, she got an emergency call from her estranged sister, Ellie, a small-town police chief, asking for her help. A 5- or 6-year-old girl had shown up in the town square, dirty, malnourished and holding a wolf pup. She either couldn’t or wouldn’t talk. Instead she growled and howled.

Upon her arrival, Julia found that the child not only exhibited the characteristics mentioned but she had the scarring characteristic of severe abuse. The plan of the sisters was two-fold. Julia would attempt to gain the child’s confidence to the point she would talk and tell who she was. At the same time, Ellie would work with the media in the hopes that her parents would recognize their daughter and come forth.

Julia’s plan hit a roadblock when it became apparent that the girl was either a “wild child” or close to it. There was no assurance that she even had language. Ellie’s plan went awry when the media discovered that disgraced Julia was involved in the case. As Julia slowly began to make progress, she discovered that the girl had rudimentary language and an uncanny ability to mimic. Ellie met one roadblock after another. As the media attention began to wane, no parents were forthcoming. Pressure was building to place the child in a residential setting where she could be studied and presumably receive more specialized help.

In a somewhat separate storyline, personal relationships were explained and examined. There was an explanation of the sisters’ estrangement — Julia’s traumatic past and Ellie’s failed marriages. There were continual hints that the handsome doctor had trauma in his past. And if that is not enough, there was the mystery of the “wild child.”

As the novel progresses, the story lines begin to merge. The untamed girl becomes enamored with being read to, especially “Alice in Wonderland,” and was thus given the name Alice. The sisters realized that they had many characteristics and goals in common. The doctor becomes involved with the case and begins to feel emotions again. And still there are problems to come.

Comments are closed.

  • Book review: ‘Nathan’s Run’ by John Gilstrap

    January 13th, 2021
    by

    I took my own advice and ordered a John Gilstrap book from Winding Rivers. “Nathan’s Run” is the book that identified Gilstrap as a writer people wanted to read.


    Royall’s Gruen among top three candidates for Pardeeville superintendent position

    January 13th, 2021
    by

    Royall School District Superintendent Mark Gruen is one of three finalists for the superintendent’s position in the Pardeeville School District, the Portage Daily Register reported Monday.


    BHS actors to perform ‘These Shining Lives’

    January 6th, 2021
    by

    Brookwood students rehearsed their dramatic performance of “These Shining Lives,” a play by Melanie Marnich, on Sunday.


    Book review: ‘Hiddensee’ by Gregory Maguire

    January 6th, 2021
    by

    “The Nutcracker” ballet has become a staple of the Christmas season (the La Crosse Dance Centre is offering a Covid-safe streaming performance in March).


    Royall teacher passes away suddenly

    January 6th, 2021
    by

    Royall students, teachers and staff are mourning the loss of a fifth-grade teacher who died unexpectedly over the holiday break.


  • After fire, Ontario house likely a loss

    January 6th, 2021
    by

    A fire resulted in significant water and smoke damage at the Mark and Tammy Smith residence on Church Street in Ontario on Dec. 29.


    Book review: ‘Crimson Phoenix’ by John Gilstrap

    December 30th, 2020
    by

    John Gilstrap is a bestselling author, and the Winding Rivers Library System has several of his books.


    Book review: ‘Churchill’s Shadow Raiders’ by Damien Lewis

    December 16th, 2020
    by

    The County Line was contacted a while ago by Kensington Publishing Corp. wondering if its book reviewer might like to receive one of their books from time to time to review.


    Brookwood theatre receives state honors; parade set for Friday in Wilton

    December 16th, 2020
    by

    Brookwood’s theatre program received all-state honors in the Wisconsin High School One-Act Theatre Festival.


    Monroe County teenager dies in traffic accident

    December 15th, 2020
    by

    A Warrens teenager has died in a two-vehicle crash that occurred on Highway 21 in the town of Byron.


    Cashton man arrested after alcohol-related crash in Ridgeville injures passenger

    December 14th, 2020
    by

    A Cashton man was arrested Wednesday, Dec. 9, after a single-vehicle rollover resulted in severe injuries to his passenger.


  • Archives