Book review: ‘The Magic Hour’ by Kristin Hannah


When one of Dr. Julia Cates’ pediatric patients committed a horrific murder, she was sued on the basis that she must have known her patient’s mental state, or if not, she should have. After a year of dealing with the media and having her standing as a leading child psychologist ruined, the judge ruled that she could not be held responsible and released her from the case. The damage was done.

As Julia was struggling to gain her equilibrium, she got an emergency call from her estranged sister, Ellie, a small-town police chief, asking for her help. A 5- or 6-year-old girl had shown up in the town square, dirty, malnourished and holding a wolf pup. She either couldn’t or wouldn’t talk. Instead she growled and howled.

Upon her arrival, Julia found that the child not only exhibited the characteristics mentioned but she had the scarring characteristic of severe abuse. The plan of the sisters was two-fold. Julia would attempt to gain the child’s confidence to the point she would talk and tell who she was. At the same time, Ellie would work with the media in the hopes that her parents would recognize their daughter and come forth.

Julia’s plan hit a roadblock when it became apparent that the girl was either a “wild child” or close to it. There was no assurance that she even had language. Ellie’s plan went awry when the media discovered that disgraced Julia was involved in the case. As Julia slowly began to make progress, she discovered that the girl had rudimentary language and an uncanny ability to mimic. Ellie met one roadblock after another. As the media attention began to wane, no parents were forthcoming. Pressure was building to place the child in a residential setting where she could be studied and presumably receive more specialized help.

In a somewhat separate storyline, personal relationships were explained and examined. There was an explanation of the sisters’ estrangement — Julia’s traumatic past and Ellie’s failed marriages. There were continual hints that the handsome doctor had trauma in his past. And if that is not enough, there was the mystery of the “wild child.”

As the novel progresses, the story lines begin to merge. The untamed girl becomes enamored with being read to, especially “Alice in Wonderland,” and was thus given the name Alice. The sisters realized that they had many characteristics and goals in common. The doctor becomes involved with the case and begins to feel emotions again. And still there are problems to come.

Comments are closed.

  • Man injured in rollover crash in Ontario

    12 hours ago

    Ontario emergency services responded to a rollover crash Thursday afternoon on Highway 33, north of the intersection with County Highway ZZ.

    Storms cause widespread damage

    16 hours ago

    Severe thunderstorms rolled through the area Tuesday evening, toppling trees and causing wind damage.

    Book review: ‘The Bookseller’ by Cynthia Swanson

    June 3rd, 2020

    Thirty-eight-year-old Kitty Miller is perfectly happy with her life. It’s the ‘60s, and except for the Cuba thing, life is good.

    Ontario Farmers Market to continue every Thursday

    June 2nd, 2020

    The Ontario Farmers Market opened for the season May 28.

    Norwalk Public Library to reopen June 8

    June 2nd, 2020

    The Norwalk Public Library will reopen Monday, June 8, with several restrictions in place.

  • Joint Brookwood/Wilton blood drive is Saturday

    June 2nd, 2020

    The cosponsors of the June 6 Red Cross blood drive in Wilton are the Brookwood High School Future Farmers of America (FFA) student club and the Wilton Area Community Drive.

    Book review: ‘Money in the Morgue’ by Ngaio Marsh and Stella Duffy

    May 27th, 2020

    When the story opens, Detective Chief-Inspector Alleyn, of the Criminal Investigative Department (CID) of Scotland Yard, is in New Zealand on a secret mission.

    Tri-Parish to begin offering Masses on Pentecost weekend

    May 27th, 2020

    Public Masses are coming again! Bishop Callahan has given permission for weekend Mass to once again be offered publicly beginning on Pentecost weekend, May 30–31.

    Book review: ‘Northanger Abbey’ by Jane Austen

    May 21st, 2020

    To properly appreciate “Northanger Abbey,” you must realize that the gothic novel (atmosphere of mystery and horror) was being widely read at the time Austen wrote the novel. It is commonly accepted that it was written as satire to that format.

    Brookwood senior parade is Friday

    May 18th, 2020

    Friday, May 22, would have been Brookwood High School students’ graduation ceremony, and to recognize our seniors, we’re hosting a senior parade Friday night.

    Norwalk-Ontario-Wilton School District will offer pick-up/drop-off dates for student materials

    May 15th, 2020

    The Norwalk-Ontario-Wilton School District will have pick-up/drop-off days for student materials from May 28–30.

  • Archives