Your right to know: Supreme Court openness rulings a mixed bag

April Barker

By APRIL BARKER

As befits a year in which anything, it seems, can happen, the Wisconsin Supreme Court’s public records docket this term was marked by atypical cases.

In Voces de la Frontera v. Clarke, the Milwaukee County Sheriff’s Department redacted information from immigration detainer forms provided in response to public records requests, asserting that a federal immigration regulation required the redactions. A Milwaukee County judge and the Wisconsin Court of Appeals concluded that federal law did not require the redactions, but the Supreme Court disagreed.

Open government advocates were disappointed that the Supreme Court’s opinion focused almost exclusively on this interpretation of federal law, not the presumptions of openness enshrined in Wisconsin statutes.

In Teague v. Schimel, the court looked at whether the Wisconsin Department of Justice violated individuals’ rights by releasing background check materials that sometimes reflected the criminal records of other individuals with the same names and birth dates or that had been used as aliases.

Those besmirched by the offenses of others argued that lives were negatively affected as a result.

The Supreme Court agreed that Teague had reason to complain that his cousin’s record was released as his. Openness advocates anticipate the ruling will not have a broad impact, because the issues it raised had less to do with transparency in government than allegations that government failed to correct defects in its process.

In Democratic Party of Wisconsin v. Wisconsin Department of Justice, the court ruled that the Department of Justice does not have to release videos of training sessions that it argued would give away sensitive information about law enforcement techniques.

This decision especially disappointed open government advocates because of majority author Justice Rebecca Bradley’s suggestion that the partisan motivation of the requester could be taken into account, contrary to how the law has previously been interpreted. Already, this argument has been invoked in other cases.

In Krueger v. Appleton Area School District, the court determined that a school committee formed to review course materials was a “governmental body” subject to the Wisconsin open meetings law, rejecting arguments to the contrary. It was a major win for openness and accountability.

And then court took a big step backward when it decided to close its own administrative rule meetings, which had previously been public. This result was unexpected and, to open government advocates, dismaying.

In its upcoming term, the court has agreed to hear Madison Teachers Union v. Scott, which stems from a union’s request for state records regarding which members had voted during a union recertification vote. The request was denied on grounds that the union would coerce and intimidate employees during the voting process.

The state Department of Justice cited Justice Bradley’s opinion regarding a requester’s motivation in a brief defending this denial.

Your Right to Know is a monthly column distributed by the Wisconsin Freedom of Information Council (www.wisfoic.org), a group dedicated to open government. April Barker is the group’s co-vice president. The group filed friend of the court briefs in the cases involving Sheriff Clarke and the Appleton Area School District.



Comments are closed.

  • Editorial cartoon

    December 12th, 2017
    by

    […]


    Book review: ‘The House on Pooh Corner’ depicts series of adventures

    December 6th, 2017
    by

    In a recent email from Lucille Hemerly, a teacher I worked with at Wilton Elementary School, she mentioned a favorite book that she used to read to her students.


    Letter to the editor: Court mandates force tobacco companies to tell the truth

    November 30th, 2017
    by

    As of Sunday, Nov. 26, the major U.S. tobacco companies are running federal court-mandated TV and print ads highlighting the negative health effects of smoking and secondhand smoke as well as how the tobacco industry designed cigarettes to be more addictive.
    Tobacco-Free Coalition member As of Sunday, Nov.


    Letter to the editor: Some Packers fans need to show some class

    November 30th, 2017
    by

    Those in attendance at the Packers-Ravens game on Sunday couldn’t help but notice there were too many Ravens fans at Lambeau Field.


    Editorial cartoon

    November 22nd, 2017
    by

    […]





  • Book review: Michael Perry’s ‘Danger, Man Working’ offers insights from a pig farmer

    November 22nd, 2017
    by

    From reviewing presidents, we move to the thoughts of self-described pig farmer Michael Perry.


    Letter to the editor: Meetings to focus on forming cooperative in Ontario

    November 22nd, 2017
    by

    Meetings to focus on forming cooperative in Ontario By Dena Eakles | Ontario If you could do one thing to help your community, what would it be?
    I have always liked the


    Letter to the editor: Every right has pro-social, common-sense limits

    November 22nd, 2017
    by

    A 4-year-old with a gun — good idea? Wisconsin’s Republican leaders think so. They just sucked up (again) to the NRA (National Rifle Association) and the gun industryby removing any age limit whatsoever from hunting in this state.


    Marklein: Thanksgiving is a good deal in Wisconsin

    November 22nd, 2017
    by

    I am already looking forward to the delicious food and time with family and friends that informally begins on Thanksgiving. I am blessed and thankful to be surrounded by family this time of the year.


    Editorial cartoon

    November 22nd, 2017
    by

    […]


    Letter to the editor: Son and namesake of Wilton American Legion’s James Leith had 38 years of federal service

    November 16th, 2017
    by

    In your November “Backtalk” column, you mention the son born to James Leith and Phyllis Bolwahn Leith. James Leith is my cousin; he was the city cousin, and I was the country cousin.


  • [Advertisement.]
  • Local Weather

  • Latest

    Multiple-win day for Royall wrestlers at Tomah

    Royall’s Noah Friedl improved to 10–0 on the season after pinning his way through the 195 bracket at the Tomah Scramble on Saturday.

    Merry music: N-O-W Elementary School students perform

    Norwalk-Ontario-Wilton Elementary School students gave their winter concert Thursday.

    Songs of the season

    Royall Middle School and Royall High School gave their holiday concerts Monday.

  • [Advertisement.]
  • [Advertisement.]
  • Archives