Your right to know: Policies put public health at risk

Christa Westerberg

By CHRISTA WESTERBERG

Wisconsin’s open government laws were meant to strengthen our democracy by ensuring an informed electorate. But, sometimes, transparency is about more than democracy — it is about human health, with serious consequences when transparency fails.

Earlier this year, the Milwaukee Journal Sentinel reported that the city of Milwaukee had failed to alert thousands of families whose children had blood tests indicating elevated lead levels. Lead from water pipes and old paint is a significant public health risk in Milwaukee and elsewhere, causing cognitive damage and other problems.

It later emerged that officials in Milwaukee had imposed a gag order on health department employees. It barred them from having contacts with elected officials without prior approval. Said one alder, “This policy is a disgrace and it likely restricted workers from coming forward sooner.” The policy has since been rescinded.

Sometimes, requests for health information and data are simply stonewalled, for no good reason. The Milwaukee Public School district failed to respond for weeks to questions about whether it tested drinking water fountains for lead. It later reported that 183 fountains had high lead levels.

And when La Crosse County learned about high levels of nitrate in drinking water wells near a large hog operation, it worked for months to get groundwater data from the Department of Natural Resources. Eventually, the county had to file open records requests, which took months to fulfill.

“If the state is keeping data on groundwater, why isn’t it sharing it willingly with its own counties, its own people, in the spirit of public health?” asked the La Crosse Tribune in an exasperated editorial. “County health officials shouldn’t be required to become experts on public-records law in order to find out whether there’s a health hazard in their own county.”

The DNR also came under fire last year for “muzzling” its scientists, preventing them from providing expert input on natural resource and other issues. Since 2011, DNR employees do not regularly testify at legislative hearings on matters within the agency’s purview.

Last year, a DNR scientist had to testify on his own time at a legislative hearing to roll back air-pollution standards. Other legislation, like a bill changing rules for managing chronic wasting disease in the state’s deer herd, had no DNR input at all.

Many public employees take seriously their duty to inform decision-makers and the public about ways to prevent health problems and lower risk. Yet some are unjustly penalized for reporting problems and sharing information. Multiple workers at the Veterans Administration hospital in Tomah, Wisconsin, were retaliated against for reporting the over-prescription of opioids and other problems.

Government agencies should always be cognizant of their duties under transparency laws. But these duties gain extra import when government holds information that can help protect public health and safety.

Taxpayers pay for the expertise of government scientists and the data they collect and generate. While some discretion may be warranted in how it is released, this information should be accessible to the public. No gag order, stonewall, or muzzle should prevent that.

Your Right to Know is a monthly column distributed by the Wisconsin Freedom of Information Council (www.wisfoic.org), a group dedicated to open government. Christa Westerberg, an attorney at Pines Bach law firm in Madison, is the group’s co-vice president.

Comments are closed.

  • Book review: Aldo Leopold’s daughter reflects on work at family shack near Baraboo

    August 16th, 2018
    by

    Estella B. Leopold, the youngest of the Leopold children, has written about her experiences at “The Shack,” the setting of Aldo Leopold’s famous “Sand County Almanac.”


    Letter to the editor: Imagine if free lunch program in Norwalk was expanded?

    August 16th, 2018
    by

    It was great to see your write up on United Methodist Church in Norwalk and the excellent service it provides to the community.


    Editorial cartoon

    August 16th, 2018
    by

    […]


    Guest view: Ideas for real change

    August 9th, 2018
    by

    Running for sheriff of Monroe County has been a remarkable experience. Not only has it allowed me the opportunity to challenge myself, but also it challenged the community to provide feedback on how they view the Monroe County Sheriff’s office and their ideas on how we should operate in the future.


    Letter to the editor: Leah Vukmir is a caring nurse, military mom, tough-minded politician

    August 9th, 2018
    by

    Over the last many months, I have gotten to know and trust Leah Vukmir. Leah is running for U.S. Senate, aiming to unseat Tammy Baldwin. 


  • Letter to the editor: Biggest challenge to single-payer system is political

    August 9th, 2018
    by

    As a physician, my responsibility is to provide the best care possible to my patients. Many factors help me fulfill that responsibility: continuing education about innovative treatments, the insights of my colleagues, and of course, the efforts of my patients themselves.


    Editorial cartoon

    August 9th, 2018
    by

    […]


    Letter to the editor: Jeremy Likely is best choice for Monroe County sheriff

    August 9th, 2018
    by

    On Aug. 14, we, the citizens of Monroe County, will have the opportunity to select which sheriff candidate will move forward to the general election.


    Letter to the editor: Vote for Paul Buhr for state Assembly

    August 9th, 2018
    by

    Vote for Paul Buhr on Aug. 14. Paul is running for the 96th Assembly position on the Democratic ballot.


    Letter to the editor: Women of Norwalk United Methodist Church doing glorious, kind, giving thing

    August 2nd, 2018
    by

    Just about the time I am feeling properly jaded and cynical and convinced the human race is doomed, you print something in your paper that forces me to renew my faith in humans.


    Letter to the editor: Likely is a man of integrity, generosity, and empathy

    August 2nd, 2018
    by

    Jeremy Likely was hired as a part-time police officer by the Village of Wilton several years ago. He is now our full-time police chief as well as ambulance director.


  • [Advertisement.]
  • Local Weather

  • [Advertisement.]
  • [Advertisement.]
  • Archives