Your right to know: Lawsuits test limits of political speech

 

Natalie A. Harris

 

By NATALIE A. HARRIS

Donald Trump says it’s just not fair.

The president, through his campaign, is suing television station WJFW-TV in Rhinelander for airing a political ad that allegedly defamed him.

“The advertisement was the product of an intentional and malicious effort to manufacture a false statement through the use of digital technology,” the lawsuit filed on April 13 in Price County Circuit Court charges. It says the station is liable for airing the “false and defamatory content.”

Produced by Priorities USA Action, a Democratic super PAC, the advertisement included clips from Trump as Covid-19 became a pandemic, including saying “this is their new hoax.”

Trump’s campaign alleges that the ad implies he called the coronavirus a hoax; it maintains that he was referring to how Democrats were politicizing the pandemic.

And so the campaign targeted stations in battleground states with a cease and desist letter, saying the ad “stitched together fragments from multiple speeches by President Trump to fraudulently and maliciously imply that President Trump called the coronavirus outbreak a ‘hoax.’”

WJFW received the cease and desist letter but continued airing the ad. Trump’s campaign sued the station for defamation. On April 27, WJFW had the case removed to federal court in Wisconsin.

Trump is not the only public official testing the language of politics in the courtroom. Wisconsin Supreme Court candidate Jill Karofsky also recently sued to block ads she claimed were defamatory.

The ads aired by outside interest groups alleged that Karofsky, as a Dane County prosecutor, “went easy” on a defendant charged in 1999 with child enticement and first-degree sexual assault of a child. He ultimately pled guilty to lesser charges and was sentenced to three years’ probation with no jail time.

Court records show that Karofsky’s involvement in the case did not begin until more than a year after sentencing, prompting the PolitiFact Wisconsin to give the ad a “pants on fire” rating, signifying that it was completely false.

Karofsky sued in Milwaukee County Circuit Court, with her campaign manager declaring, “No organization should get away with spending millions of dollars on ads they know are false.”

But a judge refused to block the ads, saying that to do so before they were determined to be defamatory would constitute an unlawful prior restraint. Karofsky went on to win the election.

Political ad defamation suits are difficult to win. But even the filing of a lawsuit, successful or not, can chill political speech. Filing suits based on negative ads and flooding battleground markets with takedown demands quiets the voice of opposition.

The Trump campaign’s lawsuit against WJFW is also a reminder of the risk broadcasters face by accepting campaign ads.

Broadcasters cannot be sued for claims made in ads placed by candidates, but suits based on ads from third parties like PACs are fair game.

WJFW may prevail on First Amendment grounds. Supreme Court precedent requires public figures to prove that speakers knew, or should have known, their statements were false but published them anyway.

That is a difficult burden, especially given decisions requiring courts to overlook small inaccuracies and protect substantially true statements — those that capture the “gist and sting” of the truth — from defamation liability.

Your Right to Know is a monthly column distributed by the Wisconsin Freedom of Information Council (wisfoic.org), a group dedicated to open government. Natalie A. Harris is a graduate of the University of Wisconsin Law School and a partner at the Chicago boutique media defense firm Baron Harris Healey.

Comments are closed.

  • Letter to the editor: County Line offers news close to home

    January 16th, 2022
    by

    I look forward to finding an issue of the County Line in my mailbox.


    New map to give Ontario options

    January 6th, 2022
    by

    A new map of Ontario reflects an attempt to allow for more flexible zoning, repairs, and the retention of older buildings in our downtown area.


    Letter to the editor: Earth is undergoing traumatic change

    January 6th, 2022
    by

    For anyone not paying attention: The earth is undergoing traumatic change.


    Letter to the editor: Police officers make a difference in communities

    January 6th, 2022
    by

    My granddaughter wants to be a police officer when she grows up to help people.


    Letter to the editor: George Wilbur is Vernon County Board candidate

    January 6th, 2022
    by

    am writing to announce my candidacy for the Vernon County Board representing the Village of Ontario, the Town of Forest, the Town of Union north of Warner Road, and most of the Town of Whitestown, where I serve as Town Chair.


  • Letter to the editor: Children should not be denied the right to think critically about nation’s history

    December 16th, 2021
    by

    Echo Valley Hope is an educational 501(c)3 nonprofit advancing sustainable living and peace. In response to recent confusion regarding the teaching or not teaching of critical race theory, we offer this:


    Your right to know: Investigation records should be public

    December 16th, 2021
    by

    Two years ago this month, a Madison East High School teacher chaperoning a Minneapolis field trip creeped into students’ rooms, using copies of their room keys, and planted hidden cameras in their bathrooms.


    Letter to the editor: Safety of students, not sports and ancient history, should take priority

    December 16th, 2021
    by

    I have been starting to search for a house in the Norwalk-Wilton-Kendall area after moving back to Wisconsin recently and took some time to read through the County Line online to get an idea of current issues and trends in the communities. 


    Guest view: Our healthcare system is on the verge of collapse

    December 16th, 2021
    by

    Will your actions/inaction be responsible for killing your neighbors or family members?


    Letter to the editor: An elaboration on N-O-W School Board meeting comments

    December 9th, 2021
    by

    I speak quite often at the N-O-W School Board meetings. In the short amount of time that the public is given, I brought up a summary of my concerns, as I am a patriot and a VERY concerned citizen.


    Editorial cartoon

    November 26th, 2021
    by

  • Archives