Your right to know: Lawsuit put end to abusive practice

Arn Pearson

By ARN PEARSON

Wisconsin’s open records law applies to all records requests, big or small. But under former Attorney General Brad Schimel, the Wisconsin Department of Justice implemented a restrictive policy that limited access based on the number of potentially responsive emails.

After being sued by the Center for Media and Democracy (CMD), the Justice Department rescinded its policy and turned over hundreds of records concerning the Affordable Care Act.

The case began last summer, when CMD asked for all records and communications regarding the ACA involving the Attorney General’s office and the Wisconsin solicitor general. The request covered an eight-month period.

At that time, Wisconsin held a leading role in a multi-state lawsuit aimed at striking down the ACA and eliminating health coverage for pre-existing conditions.

The department acknowledged identifying 1,940 records potentially responsive to CMD’s request, but claimed it would be “excessively burdensome” to review and redact them. It also claimed the request was not reasonably limited as to subject matter or time. It denied the request.

CMD filed suit in response and, in the course of the litigation, learned that Schimel’s office had adopted a policy of rejecting open records requests based on an arbitrary 500-email threshold.

The DOJ’s rule pertained to potentially responsive emails, not actually responsive emails. Requesters are then pressured to narrow the scope of their request.

The problem? While the open records law does require requests to have “a reasonable limitation as to subject matter or length of time,” there is no “burdensomeness” exception, and the 500-email threshold is not recognized anywhere in state law.

In May, the department backed off in a settlement with CMD that states the policy “is no longer in place and that references to this policy have been removed from the Department of Justice website.” The change came after the state elected a new attorney general, Josh Kaul.

“This is a victory for the public and journalists, and recognizes that Schimel’s policy went too far in denying the public’s right to know,” says Christa Westerberg, an attorney representing CMD. Westerberg also serves as co-vice president ofthe Wisconsin Freedom of Information Council.

In addition, Kaul’s Justice Department has affirmed that public officials cannot defeat Wisconsin’s open records law by using private email or other digital dodges. There has been a growing national trend in which major influence operations, such as the Republican Attorneys General Association (RAGA) and American Legislative Exchange Council (ALEC), use online apps or members-only portals to evade state records retention and freedom of information laws.

In RAGA’s case, corporations that donate $25,000 or more are able to purchase access to an online site called the “Briefing Room,” where Republican AGs and their staff may review policy documents, draft briefs and regulatory letters, and convene regular policy conference calls using RAGA’s 501(c)(4) arm, the Rule of Law Defense Fund.

But the CMD-DOJ settlement says materials that otherwise meet the definition of records are “not exempt from disclosure by virtue of their location on private email accounts, online apps, or file-sharing services.”

Documents obtained by CMD concerning Schimel’s ACA litigation will be analyzed and published on the group’s websites, ExposedbyCMD.org and PRWatch.org.

Your Right to Know is a monthly column distributed by the Wisconsin Freedom of Information Council (wisfoic.org), a group dedicated to open government. Arn Pearson is executive director of the Center for Media and Democracy, a nonprofit investigative watchdog group focused on corporate influence and money in politics.

Comments are closed.

  • Editorial cartoon

    September 13th, 2019
    by

    […]


    Your right to know: Abrahamson let the sunshine in

    August 28th, 2019
    by

    As Justice Shirley Abrahamson ends her tenure on the Wisconsin Supreme Court, after 43 years and more than 1,300 authored opinions, she leaves a rich legacy of legal scholarship, importantly including her support for government transparency.


    Editorial cartoon

    August 28th, 2019
    by

    […]


    Letter to the editor: What will happen to state parks that don’t draw affluent, urban visitors?

    August 28th, 2019
    by

    In his most recent “E-Update,” Sen. Howard Marklein (17th District) touts alleged improvements to Wisconsin’s state parks, particularly Peninsula State Park, a unique park in Door County that is frequented by affluent visitors from Chicago and other urban centers.


    Letter to the editor: Urge Whitestown Town Board to deny variance for 5G tower

    August 15th, 2019
    by

    I would like to encourage residents of Whitestown Township to write the town board to deny Bug Tussel a variance on the tower to be built on Dutch Hollow Road.


  • Letter to the editor: Law curbs local control over cell-tower siting

    August 15th, 2019
    by

    Concerned about Bug Tussel cell towers (for wireless internet)? Depending on authorities and zoning laws of town or village to protect you?


    Letter to the editor: Disaster recovery should never become political

    August 7th, 2019
    by

    After torrential rains and disastrous flooding devastated communities along the Elroy-Sparta and 400 bike trails, community leaders and state representatives rallied together to find solutions.


    Editorial cartoon

    July 11th, 2019
    by

    […]


    Letter to the editor: Much prayer given for Ontario’s special day

    July 11th, 2019
    by

    Have you ever paused … perhaps I use a more emphatic word … STOPPED to believe something?


    Letter to the editor: 5G towers emit microwaves

    July 11th, 2019
    by

    There is something new on the horizon. AT&T joined forces with Bug Tussle to bring the world-touted 5G to our doors.


    Letter to the editor: Take time to help children in detention centers

    July 4th, 2019
    by

    Concentration camps. I’m sure you’ve heard these words in the news lately. They’ve been around since medieval times and are still being used today.


  • [Advertisement.]
  • Archives