Your right to know: Don’t purge records of expunged cases

 

April Barker

 

By APRIL BARKER

Wisconsin legislators are looking to reform current law governing the expungement of criminal records.

Among other things, SB-39 would allow those convicted of crimes for which the maximum term of imprisonment is six years or less (including some felonies) to ask a judge to expunge their convictions even if they fail to do so at the time of sentencing, as is currently required.

It would also allow those older than age 25 at the time of an offense to request expungement, and expressly provide that an expunged record cannot be considered a conviction for purposes of employment. The standard under present law would be carried forward, which lets judges grant expungement if they determine “that the person will benefit and society will not be harmed.”

The rationale for the bill, which has broad bipartisan support, is to give those who have made minor mistakes a fresh start, including supposedly enhanced employment opportunities. It is one of several current proposals to expand the availability of expungement. Gov. Tony Evers has called for expunging convictions for individuals convicted of possessing small amounts of marijuana, and legislators are looking to allow expungement for first-offense drunken driving.

Currently, when a case is expunged, the court file is sealed and the record removed from the state’s online court records system, Wisconsin Circuit Court Access program. Supporters of these bills consider this removal of records an essential component of expungement. (Last year, in a similar vein, the director of state courts implemented a policy removing, after two years, dismissed criminal cases from WCCA.)

While the goal of assisting people in moving past their pasts is laudable, we would do well to remember the words of the late U.S. Supreme Court Justice Louis D. Brandeis, who wrote, “Experience teaches us to be most on our guard … when the government’s purposes are beneficent.”

Wisconsin’s open records law declares that denying access to information about the actions of government is generally contrary to the public interest. That may be especially true when the information being removed involves the actions of law enforcement agencies and courts, both of whom are entrusted with great powers that are subject to abuse.

The goal of erasing criminal convictions for those who are deserving can be accomplished without removing records from public view. Employers already may not legally discriminate in hiring unless the circumstances of the conviction “substantially relate to the circumstances” of the job, or in other similarly limited instances.

Proponents of removing information assert that people are frequently denied employment because of minor or long-ago criminal convictions. But in fact, the vast majority of people with criminal convictions do manage to find work. The state has 1.4 million people with criminal pasts, according to one group pushing for expungement reform; the state’s unemployment rate is 3 percent, or about 94,000 workers.

Ceding the right to know what our government is doing is a slippery slope that has no identifiable stopping point. The denial of access to information about government activity unquestionably undermines our ability to know what our government is doing and has done.

In this case, there is little empirical evidence supporting the reasons for limiting access, however honorable the government actors’ intentions may be.

Your Right to Know is a monthly column distributed by the Wisconsin Freedom of Information Council (wisfoic.org), a group dedicated to open government. April Barker, the Council’s co-vice president, is an attorney with Schott, Bublitz & Engel of Brookfield.

 

 

 

Comments are closed.

  • Letter to the editor: Hauge most qualified for Vernon County Register of Deeds

    August 5th, 2020
    by

    On Aug. 11, we will vote for the next Register of Deeds in Vernon County. I served as the Vernon County Register of Deeds for the last 14 years of my 32 years with Vernon County before retiring last year.


    Letter to the editor: Why I support Derrick Van Orden for Congress

    August 5th, 2020
    by

    Derrick is a warrior; he is a retired Navy Seal; he defended our country from the evils of the world; he swore to protect the Constitution of the United States from enemies foreign and domestic; Derrick loves our country.

    This content is for County Line Monthly and County Line Yearly members only.
    Log In Register

    Editorial cartoon

    August 5th, 2020
    by

    Letter to the editor: Politics with a purpose

    August 5th, 2020
    by

    Being a member of the Republican Party (for me) has not always meant voting straight Republican.


    Letter to the editor: Deb Carney deserves your vote for Monroe County Treasurer

    August 5th, 2020
    by

    Deb Carney has spent 34 years serving the people of Monroe County and she has served us well.


  • Letter to the editor: Jessi Ebben best candidate for U.S. Congress

    August 5th, 2020
    by

    I am Kristen Gust, a full-time inside sales manager, an owner/operator of my own small business, a combat veteran, and the mayor of the city of Sparta.


    Letter to the editor: Vote for Carney for Monroe County Treasurer

    August 5th, 2020
    by

    I am writing this letter to show my endorsement for Debra Carney, who is running for Monroe County Treasurer.


    Letter to the editor: Vote Jessi Ebben Aug. 11

    August 5th, 2020
    by

    In the Aug. 11 primary elections, the candidates will be selected to be the party nominees for Representative from Wisconsin’s 3rd Congressional District.


    Letter to the editor: Vote for Dawn Nemec in Vernon County primary

    August 5th, 2020
    by

    I want to remind all eligible voters that the Wisconsin primary election is being held Tuesday, Aug. 11, 2020.


    Letter to the editor: Black Lives Matter movement is problematic

    August 5th, 2020
    by

    I offer this response to Melissa Murray in an effort to highlight why the Black Lives Matter movement is problematic.


    Letter to the editor: Response to editorial by Doug Rogalla

    July 22nd, 2020
    by

    I offer this response to Doug Rogalla, Monroe County Republican Party Chair, in an effort to highlight the Black Lives Matter organization and the reason they exist and for what purpose.


  • [Advertisement.]
  • Archives