Letter to the editor: Sen. Tiffany, mining companies need to cover costs of damages

By DON FOY | La Farge

A recent editorial by state Sen. Tom Tiffany (R – Hazelhurst) finds fault with the premise of “anticipatory nuisance,” which is being used as basis of a lawsuit to stop a sand mining operation in Jackson County.

There are a few layers of irony here. While no one can prove in advance that a mine will be a nuisance, common sense and experience shows that mines often do cause air and water pollution, increased traffic, excess noise, and decreased property values.

No one can prove that the mine will be a nuisance, but Tiffany and the mining company can’t prove that the mine will be harmless either. So, fair’s fair: let Sen. Tiffany and the mining company vouch for the mine. If the court decides for the mine, and it causes no damage, fine; its proponents can make their investments and get richer.

But if it does do damage, they would have to pay to fix it. That would include loss to property values and tourism income.

The larger irony is that Sen. Tiffany says anticipatory nuisance will also undermine local control. In 2014, Tiffany co-sponsored a bill limiting the ability of towns and municipalities to control mines. He said all such places are “trying to establish mini DNRs.”

But that bill also restricted the DNR from setting reclamation standards. Recent history shows Republicans don’t want an effective DNR at all. They’re doing whatever it takes to wrest power from citizens and hand it to corporations.

Comments are closed.

  • Editorial cartoon

    October 4th, 2019
    by

    […]


    Editorial cartoon

    October 3rd, 2019
    by

    […]


    Letter to the editor: Trump and tariffs

    October 3rd, 2019
    by

    I met a friend from Gilman Township recently at a rural farm meeting where he expressed concern that President Trump’s continued and increased tariffs with China is hurting farmer’s income.


    Editorial cartoon

    September 13th, 2019
    by

    […]


    Your right to know: Abrahamson let the sunshine in

    August 28th, 2019
    by

    As Justice Shirley Abrahamson ends her tenure on the Wisconsin Supreme Court, after 43 years and more than 1,300 authored opinions, she leaves a rich legacy of legal scholarship, importantly including her support for government transparency.


  • Editorial cartoon

    August 28th, 2019
    by

    […]


    Letter to the editor: What will happen to state parks that don’t draw affluent, urban visitors?

    August 28th, 2019
    by

    In his most recent “E-Update,” Sen. Howard Marklein (17th District) touts alleged improvements to Wisconsin’s state parks, particularly Peninsula State Park, a unique park in Door County that is frequented by affluent visitors from Chicago and other urban centers.


    Letter to the editor: Urge Whitestown Town Board to deny variance for 5G tower

    August 15th, 2019
    by

    I would like to encourage residents of Whitestown Township to write the town board to deny Bug Tussel a variance on the tower to be built on Dutch Hollow Road.


    Letter to the editor: Law curbs local control over cell-tower siting

    August 15th, 2019
    by

    Concerned about Bug Tussel cell towers (for wireless internet)? Depending on authorities and zoning laws of town or village to protect you?


    Letter to the editor: Disaster recovery should never become political

    August 7th, 2019
    by

    After torrential rains and disastrous flooding devastated communities along the Elroy-Sparta and 400 bike trails, community leaders and state representatives rallied together to find solutions.


    Your right to know: Lawsuit put end to abusive practice

    July 11th, 2019
    by

    Wisconsin’s open records law applies to all records requests, big or small.


  • [Advertisement.]
  • Archives