Book review: ‘Mr. Dickens and His Carol’ by Samantha Silva


“Mr. Dickens and His Carol” is a work of fiction. That must be understood to appreciate this review. The story does contain “rich historical detail from Charles Dickens’ life.” I’ll leave it to you to do the research necessary to determine what “rich historical detail ….”

Dickens was known for his largesse. He was constantly approached to support orphans, the poor and several his relatives. Besides that, his wife lived in a style that required money. The generous lifestyle suited the successful author well. He was recognized wherever he went, and he enjoyed the notoriety. But lately another author was intruding. William Makepeace Thackery had begun making a name for himself. As if that wasn’t enough, Dicken’s latest installments of “Martin Chuzzlewit” weren’t selling.

Suddenly money was not so plentiful. Dickens began to resent the demands upon him; in fact, it didn’t look like he could meet them. This was especially troubling when he couldn’t make his wife understand that they would have to limit the children’s lavish Christmas. And that they were not in a position to hold the usual large Christmas party.

His agent explained that there was a way out: His publisher wanted a Christmas book. It would have to be written quickly so that it could be printed in time for Christmas sales, a task that seemed impossible to Dickens, as he didn’t have the foggiest idea of a subject.

Dicken’s wife became so upset with his penny-pinching ways that she took the children and went to her parents.

With no reason to stay in his now lonely house, he went back to the hotel where he’d lived when his work first found success. But without ideas, the writer’s block remained, and with each passing day, the chance of completing a successful Christmas book lessoned. Whenever Charles Dickens was attempting to reconstruct his situation, he took a long night walk in some areas of London. On one of those walks, he had occasion to accompany a young woman to her door as she left the theater. There seemed to be a mutual attraction. It turned out that she was a devoted reader of his writing; it had special meaning to her, and therefore he did too. She also had a son, Tim, who currently had a leg injury that caused him to have to use a crutch. Dickens made no secret of the fact that he had a wife and family. In fact, he emphasized how much he missed them.

But he was lonely, and it looked as though his wife might never come back. So he used every occasion to get to know the young woman, Elenore Lovejoy, and her son. In fact, he began to believe that she was his muse. He enthusiastically began to write, drawing on the experiences gained in his past and present. Tiny Tim came into the story, as did his penny-pinching ways and many of the people around him, along with the name, Scrooge. We know that the “Christmas Carol” got written, but did his wife and family return? What becomes of the Elenore Lovejoy and Tiny Tim?

Comments are closed.

  • Book review: ‘Money in the Morgue’ by Ngaio Marsh and Stella Duffy

    May 27th, 2020

    When the story opens, Detective Chief-Inspector Alleyn, of the Criminal Investigative Department (CID) of Scotland Yard, is in New Zealand on a secret mission.

    Tri-Parish to begin offering Masses on Pentecost weekend

    May 27th, 2020

    Public Masses are coming again! Bishop Callahan has given permission for weekend Mass to once again be offered publicly beginning on Pentecost weekend, May 30–31.

    Book review: ‘Northanger Abbey’ by Jane Austen

    May 21st, 2020

    To properly appreciate “Northanger Abbey,” you must realize that the gothic novel (atmosphere of mystery and horror) was being widely read at the time Austen wrote the novel. It is commonly accepted that it was written as satire to that format.

    Brookwood senior parade is Friday

    May 18th, 2020

    Friday, May 22, would have been Brookwood High School students’ graduation ceremony, and to recognize our seniors, we’re hosting a senior parade Friday night.

    Norwalk-Ontario-Wilton School District will offer pick-up/drop-off dates for student materials

    May 15th, 2020

    The Norwalk-Ontario-Wilton School District will have pick-up/drop-off days for student materials from May 28–30.

  • Book review: ‘Rooster Bar’ by John Grisham

    May 13th, 2020

    Foggy Bottom was a for-profit law school in Washington D.C.

    Celebrating dairy: Individuals, organizations donate to school lunch programs

    May 13th, 2020

    A flurry of dairy donations has been made to local schools over the past few weeks.

    Brookwood blood drive will be at Wilton Community Center

    May 6th, 2020

    The Wednesday, May 13, Red Cross blood drive hosted by the Brookwood High School FFA will now be held at the Wilton Community Center.

    Book review: ‘Us Against You’ by Fredrik Backman (translator Neil Smith)

    May 5th, 2020

    “Beartown” introduces us to a hockey town, and not just any hockey town, but a relatively small, rural community in the forests of Sweden that has been a hockey town to be reckoned with in the past.

    Wilton woman sentenced to probation for selling narcotic prescription medications

    May 1st, 2020

    Karri Jo Asselin, 44, of Wilton was sentenced on April 28 in Monroe County Circuit Court to four years of probation for manufacturing/deliver schedule I, II narcotics/party to a Crime.

    Book review: ‘Drive Your Plow Over the Bones of the Dead’ by Olga Tokarczuk

    April 29th, 2020

    Janina Duszeijko is a retired bridge building engineer who lives on a mountain plateau near the Czech Republic.

  • Archives