Book review: ‘Down a Dark Road’ by Linda Castillo


Chief Kate Burkholder grew up with Joseph King. Like Kate, he was Amish at the time, a neighbor and her first love. After his father died in a buggy accident, Joseph changed, and they lost touch until now, 20 years later.

A year ago, Joseph had been convicted of the shotgun murder of his wife. And now he had escaped from prison. Since his five children had been placed with an aunt near Painter’s Mill, it was possible he would turn up there. Smart money was on a quick escape as far away as possible, perhaps Canada.

Of course, it wouldn’t be much of a story if he hadn’t returned. Through a series of events, he not only returns to claim his children, but manages to chase away the aunt and uncle and force Kate into the house — a hostage situation. He doesn’t want Kate as a hostage, though; he needs her help to prove his innocence.

In the meantime, all of the police in the area have arrived, including the SWAT squad. Lights are flashing, negotiating attempts are being made, and Kate is trying to get Joseph to accept what she feels is reason. Among other things, this is too dangerous for the children. At this point, the reader sees no good way out of the situation. King must sleep sometime, he’s badly outnumbered, etc.

That’s where it stands when Kate is sent away to find out what she can. Her pleas for leniency fall on deaf ears as Joe is seen as a desperate killer and her observations as the naive beliefs resulting from her former friendship. Even if he is innocent, which is doubtful, how is she going to have time to prove that to save Joseph?

With a good deal of old-fashioned detective work, it begins to look like King could possibly be innocent. But how to prove it to the skeptical? And why are they so hell bent to bring this to a conclusion regardless? The original set of “facts” appear distorted. As this is uncovered, the regular reader of the Burkholder books begins to see the formula emerge. Kate is going to be put in at least one more life-threatening situation before the conclusion of the book. The mystery at this point, besides the one central to story, is who or what will save her?

It is usually my wife Arlis who finds factual or editorial mistakes in a book. Though not necessarily central elements to the story, they can be distracting. I found two factual errors right away but did not note others. Castillo uses the terms “rifle” and “shotgun” interchangeably early in the book. Also, there is the “flash of a sunfish” in the creek below. Unless the sunfish escaped from a nearby lake, that is very unlikely. That said, I included them in the review just to prove that I was paying attention.

“Down a Dark Road” is a good mystery. Though it is a part of a series, you can, and perhaps should, pick it up and read it now. It stands up very well, even if you haven’t read the previous books.

Comments are closed.

  • ‘Backtalk’: Dispatches from a Covid-19 hospital bed — Take this virus seriously!

    9 hours ago

    I had hoped that the Covid-19 virus would miss us. After all, all we are in an isolated valley, and for so long, things were very, very quiet, but we should’ve known it was not meant to last.

    Book review: ‘The Sherlockian’ by Graham Moore

    10 hours ago

    From Wiktionary: Sherlockian (plural Sherlockians) — A Sherlock Holmes scholar or fan; one who studies and/or appreciates the works of Sir Arthur Conan Doyle.

    Monroe County to offer WIC benefits

    17 hours ago

    The Monroe County Special Supplemental Nutrition Program for Women, Infants and Children (WIC) will issue benefits and offer nutrition education in October.

    Town of Wilton crash results in fatality

    September 29th, 2020

    A rural Tomah woman died today in a two-vehicle traffic crash at the intersection of Highway 131 and County Highway A in the town of Wilton.

    Book review: ‘The Winter Soldier’ by Daniel Mason

    September 23rd, 2020

    In 1914, through a series of complicated events, the Austro-Hungarian Empire found itself in what turned out to be World War I.

  • Vernon County Sheriff’s Office releases statement on reports of alleged attempted kidnappings

    September 23rd, 2020

    The Vernon County Sheriff’s Office today released the following statement on viral social media posts regarding alleged attempted kidnapping of Amish.

    Book review: ‘Kitchens of the Great Midwest’ by J. Ryan Stradal

    September 16th, 2020

    It is helpful to know that “Kitchens of the Great Midwest’’ has a goodly number of characters described in different stages of their lives.

    KVR managed-grazing program set for Sept. 26

    September 16th, 2020

    The Kickapoo Valley Reserve will host a Ralph Nuzum Lecture Series program entitled “Can Managed Grazing Improve Soil Health and Water Quality in the Driftless Area?” on Saturday, Sept. 26.

    Monroe County Local History Room in Sparta wants you to vote for your favorite toys

    September 16th, 2020

    The Monroe County Local History Room’s polls are now open to cast your vote for the most beloved toys made from the 1940s through 1990s.

    Book review: ‘Margaret’s War’ by Bill Stokes

    September 11th, 2020

    World War II was well underway, and 13-year-old Billy Forrest was missing it. He had no chance to be a war hero, and what chance would he have with the girls when the heroes returned?

    Brookwood theatre’s performances set for this weekend

    September 10th, 2020

    Commemorating, consoling, and persevering are a few of the adjectives invoked by Brookwood theatre’s fall production of “Women and War” and “Who’s on First?

  • Archives