Guest column: Children teach us wonder and encourage us to act

By DEB SEVERSON

Member of Save Our Unique Lands (SOUL) and Citizens Energy Task Force (CETF)

Children approach life with an inquisitive sense of wonder and a thirst for learning. They dream of what can be and challenge us by unceasingly asking why.

When the fifth grade students at Evergreen Elementary in Holmen researched and weighed in on whether to build the Badger-Coulee transmission line, the result was more than “an admirable exercise in getting kids to think … ” It was an inspirational lesson for us all.

Rather than accept that battles waged about high-voltage regional transmission lines are between not-in-my-backyard challengers and straight-line engineers, or coal versus renewable energy, we should get curious, educated and involved.

Rather than accept that more transmission will improve the reliability and environmental impact of our grid, we need to relentlessly ask why, especially when the stakes are so high.

• Why, when energy efficiency is the fastest way to save money, reduce our carbon footprint and increase grid reliability, is there disproportionate focus on transmission? Is it the fact that utility profits decrease when energy efficiency and ratepayer-owned renewables increase that suppresses viable alternatives?

• Why do for-profit transmission companies make over 50 percent operating income when the average for all U.S. industries is 17 percent? Is this why Xcel Energy and American Transmission Company (ATC) waged a federal battle over who should own the Badger Coulee line?

• Why sacrifice our lands when there are better ways? Why risk human, animal and avian well-being by ignoring research on the risks of UV, ionizing radiation and EMF emitted from high-voltage lines?

Keeping the lights on is a compelling marketing message. But the reality is we’ve known since the ’70s that transmitting centrally generated electrons to distant load centers, be they renewable or fossil-fuel based, presents national security and reliability issues.

Recognition of these shortcomings led to a 2012 conclusion by the then-chairman of the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission that the nation’s electrical future may well belong to distributed generation such as rooftop solar, rather than central power stations and generators far from demand.

Which takes us back to wondering …

• Why build more centralized generation and more wires to send it even more places when it is unreliable, inefficient and vulnerable?

• Why perpetuate a business model that rewards utilities based on increased consumption and increased infrastructure, which is incompatible with the urgent need to address climate change?

• Why not evaluate all alternatives equally for their carbon reduction, reliability and cost-savings benefits? Would doing so lead us down another path?

Like the telephone industry, which fundamentally changed and improved due to wireless technologies, the electrical industry has the unprecedented opportunity to transform in a user-friendly way and create jobs, save money and address global climate change along the way.

But it requires a new path.

It also requires that we scrutinize strategies to extend the “old way,” as regional transmission does for centralized generation. And it requires recognizing that fossil fuel interests and utilities benefit from centralization, and they’ll work to protect this.

Encouragingly, many states are taking the fork in the road by implementing aggressive energy efficiency goals and removing barriers to ratepayer-owned renewables. We ask the Wisconsin Public Service Commission to do the same.

In Minnesota, the Public Utilities Commission and innovative utilities are proving solar can be a better option than natural gas when all costs and benefits are accounted for. California and some East Coast states are investing in local, self-sufficient “micro-grids,” enabling reliability, resiliency and significant carbon reduction.

Following the lead of the fifth-graders finds us wishing for more innovation and thoughtful consideration of all our options in Wisconsin and wondering which way is best for their future. Rather than accept status quo, we heed the inspirational words of Margaret Mead, “Never doubt that a small group of thoughtful, committed citizens can change the world; indeed, it’s the only thing that ever has.”

Comments are closed.

  • Tractor pull enthusiasts gather in Wilton

    July 14th, 2021
    by

    The Wilton Sportsmen’s Club hosted its tractor pull Sunday in the village’s downtown.


    Letter to the Editor: Nerison is not a ‘moderate Republican’

    October 29th, 2014
    by

    By DON FOY | La Farge  A recent article in a local newspaper described Lee Nerison, a representative for the […]


    Letter to the Editor: The elephant in the room

    October 29th, 2014
    by

    By ERIC ZINGLER | Kendall Michael Caruso, editor in chief of Smithsonian Magazine, stated in the April 2013 travel issue, […]


    Letter to the Editor: Little libraries are great

    October 22nd, 2014
    by

    By JILL MUEHLENKAMP | Norwalk The little libraries popping up in every town are great. I’ve been using Norwalk’s on […]


    Letter to the Editor: Town of Wilton shouldn’t allow quarry

    October 15th, 2014
    by

    By LARRY ROSS | Wilton “Blasting, property damage and more.” These are the words used by the Save Our Knapp […]


  • Letter to the Editor: Wilton’s credibility is on the line

    October 15th, 2014
    by

    By ERIC ZINGLER | Kendall The Backtalk editorial posted Sept. 24 stated, “It will be the Wilton Town Board’s challenge […]


    Letter to the Editor: Proposed town of Wilton quarry shouldn’t pose dangers

    October 8th, 2014
    by

    By MAHLON DENTER | rural Wilton As a resident of the town of Wilton, I see no harm to the environment […]


    Letter to the Editor: Vote for Ed Brooks

    October 8th, 2014
    by

    By DOUG ROGALLA | Kendall Elections matter! I remember just a few years ago, when I was new in the […]


    Letter to the Editor: The canary in the mine?

    October 8th, 2014
    by

    By ERIC ZINGLER | Kendall In years past, some miners would carry a caged canary into their mine. If the […]


    Letter to the Editor: Town of Wilton Board should vote no on quarry

    October 8th, 2014
    by

    By JOAN RIPP | Wilton Why should the Town of Wilton Board vote no Tuesday, Oct. 21? Lets look at […]


    Editorial cartoon

    October 8th, 2014
    by

  • Archives